When is Looting Acceptable?

More Articles Related to Psychology

Here is an interesting moral question: when is looting OK? Survival Forum has a post about this topic, which I think is an excellent read for anybody who thinks they could be in just this kind of situation.

As you read the posts in this thread, try to think from the point of view of a disaster survivor wandering your neighborhood. What if your friends and neighbors are tired and hungry, perhaps attempting to support their family but having little or nothing of their own with which to do so?

Or picture yourself in a disaster area with no relief in sight for days to come. Should you walk into someone else’s home and obtain food and survival supplies for your family? Or should you go without while all those supplies go unused right next door? Where do you draw the line in helping yourself to other people’s property? What if you and your family are starving to death while your next door neighbor is boiling a big pot of beef stew in his back yard?

When you think about it, the answers are not all black and white. I think that anybody, no matter how upstanding, could turn looter under the right conditions.

Comment on the Survival Topics article "When is Looting Acceptable?".
Your name:

Your location:

Add your comments here:

Dr Huntington
People loot for a variety of reasons. Modern archaeologists digging up graves is a form of looting that society accepts. When conditions are right, anyone might take that which does not belong to them - and when a matter of survival all bets are off.
Jen
I agree with the Doc. One person's looting is another persons livelihood and sometimes even accepted by society. When it comes to trying to survive in bad conditions you have to just do what it takes to get by.
Lisa
Survival looting is completely different than looting for fun and profit. If it is a matter of putting food on the table or going hungry of course you are going to have to loot during and emergency.
joeblkwolf
pa

You have to keep in mind the good possibility of something happening to you, then who will take care of your loved ones?

Mindmesh
Philadelphia

When the ones you love are going hungry it's ok to loot abandoned residences and business. Looting an occupied home is never ok, but I'd do so, without hesitation, if it came down to breaking my moral code or watching my son starve.

O Smith
WA, USA

I'll tell you what, if my family and I were starving to death and my neighbor were boiling a big pot of beef stew in his back yard and not sharing, then getting looted would be the least of his worries.

Shellie
Austin TX

I read somewhere that there was a study done. The conclusion- people will steal and loot beginning 3 days after a disaster with no supplies. They will begin to kill for food at about 7 days.

DB
Georgia

Mr Smith, why should your neighbor share his stew? He was prepared and you weren't. Would YOU share if you were in his shoes? Never let anyone know how you have prepared for a disaster, even family members. If you invite one family member, chances are better than average that they will invite someone else. Fairly quickly, you will find yourself a target. As for answering the question, I would condone looting unoccupied buildings for feeding your family only. Looting occupied buildings will most likely get you dead.

sara
ohio

I guess everyone will do what they have to. If you're unprepared and your son is beginning to starve, maybe you have to sneak into your neighbor's backyard in an attempt to steal his food. If your neighbor has to protect his food to ensure that there will be enough for his family to eat, All bets are off.

TnRedneck
TN

Part of the moral dilemma is the question - "When is it looting and when is it stealing?" or "When does looting become stealing?" I think most of us would agree that 'looting' a wide screen television from a store during a disaster is stealing. Jen says, "One person's looting is another persons livelihood...." This makes it sound like an everyday event and I totally disagree this is sometimes acceptable. Just because I have a spare battery in my garage and someone needs a battery, I don't give them the right nor do they have the right just to take mine.

During a disaster in times of life and death people are forced to ask themselves,"Am I my brothers keeper?" Your first duty is to you and your family (as you may define family.) If I had prepared, had laid in supplies, had a pot of beefstew cooking in the backyard and a neighbor was starving and ASKED if they could share - I probably would share. If the circumstances were the same and they clandestinely invited themselves to share - we would have a major problem if I caught them. Exploring unoccupied homes and businesses for life saving sustance that would otherwise spoil and become wasted could be understandable. Doing the same to occupied homes and businesses is unacceptable.

Octavio
Nicaragua

When is looting acceptable? Never!! It should never be acceptable, but having said that, it becomes necessary when you have no other option. That is why they have websites like this one, to learn how to prepare for hard times so looting won't be necesary. Always prepare for the worst(earthquake, hurracaine, war, flood and civil unrest), learn survival skills and practice what you have learned, buy all the necesary equipment (first aid kits, bag-out bags, food supplies, water, personal hygiene, knives, ammo flashlights etc.) and keep enough food and water for every memeber of your family including your pets for at least a 30 day supply. One thing I learned from having gone through a civil war, money or jewelry won't do you any good. Stack up with cigarrettes, or any kind of inexpensive booze, because all those smokers and drinkers will find food for you in exchange for cigarrettes or booze, so those items become more precious than gold or money, but do't tell them you have plenty otherwise they will kill you to take it all, carry a couple of packs of cigs or pints of booze with you to barter with. For some reason people can do away with eating for a few days but cannot stop smoking or drinking for half a day. Another bartering item is medicine for cold, flu, headaches, diarrhea, nausea pain and antibiotics because people will get sick. You will be amazed how much food and water you will get for a pack of cigarrettes and a pint of booze. Always be vigilant and protect your family from looters and thugs always carry your weapon with you at all times and teach all of your family members how to use one. When disaster hits, you are all alone, 911 will not work!! You must survive on your own.

Rev. C.Sage
Akron Ohio

Well I tell you what even though i am a man of the cloth when it comes to my family living or dying i want them to live. So at all cost no matter who i have to take from even if it is with force i will feed them. But i will share with people who help collect the food. starving to death is painful. and if food or the means to get it is sittin some where not being used then i will use it. i will not though share with someone capable of getting food for them self just too lazy to do so.

You are welcome to share this Survival Topic with others. I only request that you use a short blurb (not the entire survival content) and this code to link to the origional:

<a href= "http://www.survivaltopics.com/survival/when-is-looting-acceptable/"> When is Looting Acceptable?</a>